Sunday, February 23, 2014

"Erased By Time and Blockbusters"

I know this article has been making the rounds (I saw it on reddit's front page last week), so many readers have presumably already seen it, but if you haven't, check out Emily Asher-Perrin's article entitled "Erased By Time and Blockbusters-the Cautionary Tale of Ron Weasley".

It's a good illustration of the difficulties that you face when turning a giant novel with a lot of character development into a two or three hour movie. Also, it shows how hard it is to balance three characters in a movie and give them all equal weight (it's much easier in a novel, which can be much longer), especially when you're dealing with three human actors who will--naturally--give different levels of performance.

One can only wonder how it might have been if the Harry Potter novels had been turned into a miniseries instead--like the Game of Thrones books have been. Turning a single novel into 10 hours of material instead of 3 hours obviously gives you more time to dedicate to each character and the unfolding of the plot can be handled in a slower, richer and more fulfilling way. It allows you to explore each character's motivations and thinking in a way that I feel the Potter characters deserved but didn't get from their film interpretations. Who knows, maybe someday someone will re-interpret it that way!


6 comments:

David said...

Similarly, Tom Bombadil in The Fellowship of the Ring.

And as TV improves, some of the grand visuals once only reserved for the cinema trickle down to that medium too.

Brant Moon said...

"One can only wonder how it might have been if the Harry Potter novels had been turned into a miniseries instead."

This is what I've always felt. The films left important keys out and were still too long (for cinema), but if treated as several episodes adding up to one arc -- would have been much better.

fastfifa14 said...

Could this have been a plot engineered by the younger Prince Maarten and the evil Wizard Darnell, who wanted to have more power in the kingdom? Therefore creating an impossible plot of war and total destruction between one of the largest city centers and the ORC King, for looting and devastating the cities and town out of their safety and wealth. And engineered a campaign to turn the people against the King and forcing him exile, while the younger Prince Maarten, and the Evil Wizard Darnell took over the kingdom for their own selfish greedy agenda.

Fifa 14 UT Coins

fifa14coins

qq terry said...

The next night the pair fifa 14 coins came to rest at the house of a very poor, but very hospitable farmer cheap fifa 14 coins and his wife. After sharing what little food they had the couple let the angels sleep in their fifa 14 coins bed where they could have a good night's rest.

dsferew said...

 I would have burned fifa 14 coins the pink candle sculpted like a rose before it melted in storage. I would have sat on the lawn with my children and not worried about grass stains. I would have cried cheap fifa 14 coins and laughed less while watching television - and more while fifa 14 coins watching life.

dsferew said...

The younger angel fifa 14 coins was infuriated and asked the older angel cheap fifa 14 coins how could you have let this happen? The first man had everything, yet you helped him, she accused. The second family had little but was willing to share everything fifa 14 coins, and you let the cow die.